Friday, November 20, 2026

Not Communism, Not Chaos: What Would Utopia Look Like? (11/20/2026)

We watched the movie Oppenheimer the other night. During our talk after the movie, we landed on communism rather than the nuclear bombs, genocide, or maybe even depression, all themes woven into the movie. Why we got to communism is probably an artifact of the political season we have been immersed in. Ads and text messages were driving us crazy at the time. Thank goodness it was all over on November 3, but then the finger pointing, strategizing, maligning, and who knows what (fighting?) will start. No rest for a democracy.

We both agreed that communism is nothing we aspire to, and we do not think it is the thing for this country. Yet politicians throw this term around left and right as if it were the most horrendous thing imaginable. In addition, socialism seems to be a dirty word as well. My wife and I eventually landed on the question of what a utopian society would look like.

During the past 50-some years we have lived in three countries that were ruled by a dictator at the time (no it is not here in the USA, although it started to feel like it before the elections). Both Uganda and North-Yemen were ruled by dictators, and Nepal had a ruthless king who was disposed by a socialist uprising. Interestingly, the king of Nepal considered himself the reincarnation of the God Vishnu. Idi Amin of Uganda considered himself the conqueror of the British Empire. Yemen’s Saleh was a more complicated figure, an authoritarian Army general who seemed to play everybody out against each other and relied on alliances. Having seen these rulers up close, we know firsthand that a utopia is not something a strongman can deliver.

Our initial conclusion was that a preferred society would be something like we experienced in western and northern Europe. Naturally these societies are far from ideal; there is still strife and conflict. However, we felt that there are many good things in these countries. Citizens need to be guaranteed a roof over their heads, food on their plates and decent healthcare. After this it gets all too complicated for a simple retired biologist/trainer like me. How do you pay for that? More taxes, smaller military? And who would be willing to work, if you received all that. You are on easy street. Import labor from other countries? I am reminded of the ICE raids, and the recent riots in France and Germany which, to my understanding, are partially fueled by the resentment about all the foreigners that work there. A sharp turn to the right or even towards fascism. What a conundrum.

So, do we encourage homelessness, hunger and disease here in the US or around the globe? I sometimes wonder if we have reached the carrying capacity of our world. I previously wrote about Malthus who predicted in the late 1700s that there will be a time that there will be too many inhabitants for the world to support. Too many rats in a cage. Hunger, fights, and deadly diseases were all affecting those rats packed in that cage. Will this eventually happen to us human rats? We are poisoning our air and causing changes to the climate. These changes are leading to floods, weather disasters, droughts, famine, and diseases. I just read that dengue fever is back in Florida. Can communism, socialism or a European system solve this?

So, if it isn’t socialism or communism that is going to save us, what should society look like? I am sick and tired of those folks who are cavalier about this all, those folks that call it fake news, and those that say this a natural progression. Progression to what? Judgement days? Others tell me innovation will keep pace with the increasing population. Peter Tiel wondered if we really need humans (or maybe that many humans). I really think we need to take a stand and fight for our survival and that of our children, grandchildren and future generations. Perhaps that is where Oppenheimer fits in after all: a reminder that what we create can threaten our survival, and that looking away is not an option.

Newport News Park, where we took a walk the other day.  What will it look like in the future?  Will the sky still be blue, the water still useable for drinking water, and the air still breathable?



No comments:

Post a Comment